A guide for collision repair shop owners

How to fire your marketing agency

It's easier than you think. Just three steps, and the first is an email we already wrote for you.

Kristen pointing at the title
Six boxes, your domain, website, Google profile, Facebook, ads and phone numbers, travel from the agency's office into your shop AGENCY YOUR SHOP

It's your stuff.
You paid for it.
Take it with you.

DomainWebsiteGoogle profileFacebookAd accountsPhone numbers
Kristen Felder

A note from Kristen

Okay. I know I can come across as pretty hard on marketing agencies. But here's the thing. The world is changing. How customers find you is changing. How they pick who fixes their car is changing. The technology changes every month. And the only ones not changing? The marketing agency retainer model, and the work of many of the agencies themselves. They're just not built to survive in the AI age.

I talk to hundreds of shop owners, right? And every week somebody calls me and says, "Kristen, I'm spending all this money on my agency and I'm not getting anything for it." After enough of those calls, I had to do something about it.

I worked with some experts and put this guide together to help you move off your agency the right way. It's not scary, and it's not a ton of work. I even wrote the email for you to send them. Fill in a few blanks and hit send.

And here's what I always tell people. This is your stuff. You paid for it. If your agency won't hand it over, well, that tells you everything you need to know, and you shouldn't have any issue firing them.

Kristen

Kristen Felder

The whole move

Three steps. That's it.

No tech skills needed. Most of the work is one email, and your agency does the gathering. Not sure what they set up? Scan your website first.

Kristen pointing at a signpost
123

Send one email

We wrote it. Add your shop's name and hit send. It asks your agency for everything you own, in writing.

Write it now →

Collect what's yours

Tick things off as they come back. Three quick questions tell you if something is really yours.

See the 10 things →

Switch and say goodbye

Move onto Collision Center, test your forms and phone, then take the agency's access away.

See how →
One rule: don't cancel first. Send the email, collect your stuff, then switch.

Free website scan

Not sure what your agency set up? Let us look.

Type your website. In a few seconds you'll see where your domain is held, where your email runs, and the tracking codes, phone numbers and tools on your site, each with what to ask your agency for.

We only read what's public: your website and your domain's records. No sign-up.

Kristen taking a picture with her phone
1

Step 1

Send one email

Fill in the boxes and the email writes itself. Send it before you give notice.

Your details

Kristen checking her watch

Takes about five minutes.

Before you send it, check your agency agreement for the cancellation period and who owns the work. Keep their reply: it's your written record of what you own.

2

Step 2

Collect what's yours

Having access isn't the same as owning it. You can log in to an account and still not control it. Three yeses means it's yours.

Try it on one account

Is it really yours?

Kristen trying keys on a key ring

The 10 things to collect

Tap one to see exactly what to ask for.

Domain name and DNS

The most important thing on this list. Whoever controls the domain controls your website and your email.

Ask for

  • Find out who owns the domain and where it is registered
  • Get admin access at the registrar, in your shop's name
  • Get access to the DNS settings
  • Note the renewal date, the price and the card it bills to
  • Keep every email-related DNS record exactly as it is during the move
Kristen holding certification plaques
Don't leave your certifications behindAsk for every certification photo, graphic and page by name. They're the proof that sets your shop apart.

Watch for these

Five traps hiding on a typical shop website

Easy to fix before you switch. A pain after. We x-rayed a typical shop site.

Collision repair you can trustFree estimates. All insurance welcome.
Get a free estimate
Review us
Email the shop
  1. 1The phone number may belong to the agency, and stop ringing when you leave.
  2. 2The estimate form may send leads to the agency's inbox, not yours.
  3. 3Review links and QR codes may run through a service you're cancelling.
  4. 4The chat or booking widget may be the agency's subscription.
  5. 5Your shop email depends on the domain's DNS records. Change nothing there by accident.
Kristen running a shop website through an x-ray machine
All 10 hidden problems, and what to do about each

Agency-owned call tracking numbers

A number you advertised for years may stop forwarding to the shop when the contract ends.

Do this: Ask if the number can be transferred to your own phone account. If not, ask for forwarding to continue while you change it everywhere it's printed.

Website forms pointing to the agency

Estimate requests may keep going to an inbox or CRM nobody at the shop checks.

Do this: Send a test request from every form and see where it lands.

Google review links

Printed QR codes, email templates and review campaigns may link through a service you are cancelling.

Do this: Scan your own QR codes and click your own review links before you cancel.

Website redirects

Replacing the website without keeping important redirects breaks links and hurts search visibility.

Do this: Keep the list of every current page address, and make sure each one still leads somewhere after the move.

Stock photo and font licences

The agency may have licensed content that can't legally be transferred or reused.

Do this: Ask which photos and fonts are licensed, and to whom.

Hidden agency subscriptions

Chat widgets, booking tools, SEO plugins and phone services can stop working after you cancel.

Do this: Get the full list of tools on your site, and who pays for each.

Facebook business ownership

Being an admin on a Facebook Page doesn't mean you control the Meta business portfolio or the ad account.

Do this: Check who owns the business portfolio itself, not just the Page.

Scheduled posts and automated messages

Old automations can keep posting outdated information, or answering customers, after the switch.

Do this: Ask for every scheduled post and automation to be listed, then paused.

Customer data in an agency CRM

Leads, consent records and message history can disappear when the agency closes its account.

Do this: Export it all before the agency closes anything.

DNS settings

Changing web hosting without protecting your email records can cut off your business email.

Do this: Write down every DNS record before any change, and keep the email ones as they are.

3

Step 3

Switch and say goodbye

Move onto Collision Center, test it, then unplug the agency. Watch your website visits and new leads for the first two weeks.

Kristen holding an unplugged cable

Test first

  • Send an estimate request from every form
  • Call every phone number on the site
  • Book a test appointment
  • Open every main page on a phone
  • Confirm email arrives at the shop
  • Scan your printed QR codes and click your review links

Then say goodbye

  • Remove the agency as owner, admin or manager everywhere
  • Change every password you shared with the agency
  • Pause old scheduled posts and automations
  • Cancel the subscriptions you no longer need
  • Keep the final invoice and their written confirmation of what you own

Your checklist

Tick it off as you go

0of 34 done

Start with step 1. It's one email.

Step 1Send the email0 of 4
Step 2Collect what's yours0 of 17
Step 3Test, switch, say goodbye0 of 13

More cars.
No agency.

Collision Center does the marketing work your agency did, and you keep control of everything.

Kristen standing with her arms crossed
That's everything. Welcome home.Your marketing is yours again.